Sunday, December 10, 2017

Tracy's - Great Falls


Tracy's Family Restaurant in Great Falls, Montana, isn't situated astride US 89.  Nope.  It's a few blocks off route.  There are no remaining original old restaurants on US 89 in Great Falls.  Tracy's is said to be the oldest diner in Great Falls so we're going to post it here as our Great Falls featured restaurant.

Tracy's definitely meets all of the typical criteria for an old school US 89 diner. First, it started in 1952. Second, people say nothing's changed since then.  Third, the food is Classic Diner fare. Fourth, it has most all its retro stuff intact.

Here's how the owners describe their place: "Tracy's has been in business since 1952 now in our second generation of ownership Still have the old time juke box with wall boxes at each booth. Last of the real home style restaurants left in the state. We have been in business for over 50 years with 2 generation of ownership. Tracy's is downtown's only 24 hour restaurant serving snacks, shakes, sundaes, burgers, spaghetti, seafood, steaks, pork noodles and the best breakfast in town. We also have food to go. Our corner lot with an antique neon sign (50 years old) is a hot spot at night and hard for travelers to miss. We seat 90 people. Come as you are diner style eating."

About half of the Yelp and Trip Advisor reviews are Excellent or Very Good.  People who like Tracy's REALLY like Tracy's.  And people who don't like Tracy's can be pretty harsh on the place.

We chose snippets from various positive reviews to give you a feel for what to expect at Tracy's.

"Tracy's feels very familiar when you walk in, possibly because the restaurant, the menu and the staff haven't changed since 1955...built in 1952 and probably  not updated much since then. Great breakfast, great service, good location."

"From the old style water and fountain glasses to the juke box's in the booths, this is just a great piece of history with very good food and real atmosphere."

"This is not some 5 star restaurant it is a 50's diner and is actually form the 50's not some made up place to look like the 50's. The food is typical diner food but that's just fine by me. The atmosphere is to die for. So many try to imitate a diner like this but this is the real deal. You need to go at least once in your lifetime just so you can see what it is like."

"Loved the place.  Classic 50's feel and taste. If you're looking for classic American diner fare, this is it. When you walk into this place it takes you back dozens of years. The decor is definitely old school diner and the ancient jukebox on every table looks great and still works."

"We laughed to ourselves listening to why the last waitress was fired and listening to the cook argue with one of the current waitresses. This was definitely a dive of a diner."

"A part of Great Falls history.
The food has always been very good,
no matter what time of day or night you drop in.
Classic simple and filling.
The waitress that just retired
had been there forever,
sorry to see her gone,
but she deserves a rest.
24 hours most days,
come by and enjoy a place that is timeless."

"Tracy's is a staple of downtown Great Falls and the perfect example of what a diner ought to be. It's welcoming, clean, cozy, and inexpensive--and the food is delicious! What a great spot to meet an old (or new) friend for breakfast and a good cup of coffee, and it is NOT pretentious like so many places nowadays. Keep it up, Tracy's!"

Click either button above to go to the
Reviews for Tracy's Family Restaurant.

Mel's - Phoenix

Mel's signature sign as it appeared 12/30/17.
Photo ©  2017 by Peter Corbett 
Mel's Restaurant in Phoenix, Arizona, has an intriguing pedigree that's worth including here for a variety of reasons.  First, Mel's signature coffee cup sign was once a charming classic of the Neon Era.  Neon showed coffee perpetually flowing out of an extra large 14 ounce cup. Second, Mel's sign has quite the history and became an icon of the TV sitcom series "Alice".  Third, Mel's has enough retro creed to warrant a stop by US 89 Heritage Tourists seeking an authentic throwback to mid-century roadside diner days, warts and all.
Mel's sign as it appeared in the "Alice" TV series intro scenes.
You can see the sign in this video: https://youtu.be/Pa8zacHlhD0
Mel's is now located at 1747 Grand Ave. (AKA: Old US 89) a little SE of the busy Mcdowell  Road, 19th Ave intersection at the Arizona State Fairgrounds.  It's very possible that the iconic Mel's sign once stood outside a small diner near where Grand meets Van Buren Street downtown.
Mel's makes no mention of US 89.
Photo ©  2017 by Peter Corbett 

Mel's American-style Comfort Food rates mostly "average" in the bulk of reviews.  No one particular menu item stand out above the others.  Breakfast meals appear to get better reviews than lunch items. About three quarters of Mel's Trip Advisor reviews are Excellent or Very Good.  Roughly two-third of Yelp's reviews are Excellent or Very Good.  YMMV!

Here are some excerpts from reviews on Yelp and Trip Advisor.

"Well, "kiss my grits," as a character on the show used to say, Mel's is worth a visit."

"There's just something comforting about a place as resolutely old school as Mel's. Mel's menu remains old school and proud of it.  The diner itself has been relatively untouched by time (even though ownership has changed hands a few times).  Before I came here I guess I was expecting something along the lines of faux nostalgia with 50's music blaring in the background and waitresses in sock hop outfits (along the lines of Phoenix's 5 & Diner franchises).  Nope.  Unpretentious, laid back, friendly, and affordable."

"Iconic restaurant. Good breakfast. Lots of food. Lots of hash browns with meals. Several good choices for breakfast. Not as many for lunch. Go early as they don't stay open very late. Fashioned after Mel's Dinner from the old TV show Alice. You will feel like you are in the real place but not overwhelmed. Nice diner with pleasant staff. Not fancy but pretty good"

While roaming the internet, we found a story by some guy who stopped at Mel's on his way through Phoenix awhile back.

"I was running on empty and needed something to grease the skids so I saw Mel's and took a chance. There's a small US Route 60 shield on the glass entry door. Door says Bon Appétit and made me laugh. The place was pretty interesting on the inside. It's bigger than I thought. It even has a private room for about 15 people. And a AZ DPS table. Luckily, I didn't see any cops. 

I had a pretty, mid-20 something Hispanic waitress.  A 40-something veteran waitress, mom type seemed to be running the show in the dining room. Yep, there was a cast of characters included a 330-pound man and his 275 pound son. There was a brawny guy with hair all the way down his back and a hanger-on street type guy who sat at different counter seats. That guy took my newspaper when I got up to look around the restaurant. 

It was fresh, unopened newspaper and I had a full cup of coffee next to it. The waitresses retrieved it for me. He mumbled about thinking that I had left, but did not apologize. Twenty-five minutes later I gave him 3 or 4 sections that I had already read. But he did not even thank me. Oh well, dude, you are where you are for a reason. You're a jerk. 

Anyway, the place is pretty cool. The breakfast burrito was greasy good. Definitely looks like a lot of regulars visit. It got pretty busy by 9 am. Probably about 15-18 booths and 12 counter stools. They also have autographed coffee mugs hung on hooks high up along the walls.  Looked like just another Saturday morning at Mel's Diner on Grand Avenue."

Click either button above to go to the
Reviews for Mel's Diner.

Here's a recap of how the iconic sign made its way to its current location.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/29069717@N02/15216599959

The Phoenix New Times did an excellent article on Mel's in 2015 that also includes some of the above sign history.

http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/restaurants/mels-diner-in-phoenix-serves-surprisingly-excellent-food-7376891

https://www.facebook.com/pg/melsdinerphoenixarizona.kissmygrits

"Alice" probably gives a reasonably accurate portrayal
of "the life & times"of a small diner waitress.
All-in-all, it appears Mel's "might" be worth a visit from US 89 Heritage Tourists.  Based on a Field Visit by on of our US 89 Team Charter Members, you're likely to get a genuine "gritty" experience at Mel's.  However, such an experience at Mel's undoubtedly provides an accurate glimpse into the daily raw reality of so many roadside diners gone bye.

The TV series "Alice" ran from 1976 to 1985.  A DVD set of each season generally cos about $27 on Amazon.  A collection of every episode from the full series can cost as much as $200.

Many Thanks to members of the Vintage Phoenix Facebook Group for helping us find Mel's!

Saturday, December 9, 2017

Idle Isle Cafe - Brigham City

What's now the Idle Isle Cafe started in 1921 as a candy store.
Brigham City's Idle Isle Cafe is a local legend.  The historic cafe began in 1921 as a candy store that morphed into a full-fledged cafe long before US 89's route traveled Brigham City's Main Street.  Today, the Idle Isle Cafe is arguably the oldest eatery still in business along US 89's entire route.
The 1920's vibe remains.

When US 89 was first designated in 1926, it ended in Spanish Fork, far to the south of Brigham City.  It wasn't until 1932 that US 89's route was extended thru Brigham City to the Canadian border at Piegan, Montana.  By that time, the Idle Isle was long past its candy store days and had become a thriving, full service cafe.

Back from the 1930's through to the early 1950's, fast food chains were mostly unknown.  Travelers were accustomed to stopping in "Mom & Pop" restaurants located along the many Main Streets traversed by the US highway network.  The Idle Isle Cafe's very prosperity and survival through the depths of The Great Depression was due in large part to the restaurant's reputation known far and wide among US 89 travelers.

Today, the Idle Isle Cafe carries on much as it did decades ago, although the lion's share of the eatery's business comes from local and regional customers.
The Idle Isle Cafe is one of the very few remaining ancestral US 89 restaurants that retains much of the original furnishings and decor.  The cafe serves a wide array of American Comfort Food and is now perhaps best known for its sweet treats such as pie, shakes and sundaes.
Here are various links to learn more about Brigham City's Idle Isle Cafe.

http://www.idleislecafe.com/

http://www.idleislecafe.com/idle-isle-history.html

http://www.idleislecafe.com/menu.html

https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g60835-d516063-Reviews-Idle_Isle_Cafe_The-Brigham_City_Utah.html

Friday, December 8, 2017

Zula's - Nogales

Zula's opened for business alongside US 89 in 1950
Ambos Nogales history goes way back in The Way Back Time Machine. Without doubt, both the American and Mexican Nogales communities have seen many a good or great restaurant grow, thrive and then disappear.  Such is the way of life of restaurants.

The oldest US Nogales restaurant also happens to be one of the city's most popular.  Zula's began in 1950 and is 67 years strong in 2017.

Zula's gets great reviews for its burgers and apple pie.  Most of the reviews give their Mexican food an "average" rating.  Based on reading all available reviews, it appears the establishment has retained at least some of its Mid Century Modern accouterments.

This is an outdated 2001 article but it's a good place to start in getting a "feel" for Zula's earlier days:

http://www.nogalesinternational.com/zulas-restaurant-a-community-icon/article_94438b23-eae8-5ad8-b3f3-f80e368e7ddf.html

Here are the Trip Advisor reviews.  Zula's ranks #5 out of 53 Nogales restaurants.

https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g31292-d527302-Reviews-Zula_s-Nogales_Arizona.html

Here are the Yelp reviews.

https://www.yelp.com/biz/papachoris-zulas-restaurant-nogales-2

Friday, December 1, 2017

The rest of Arizona US 89


Time has taken its toll on old US 89 diners and restaurants.  Few originals remain. Faux 50's diners are making a feeble comeback but fall far short of the icons they emulate.  In this post, we take you through "the rest of Arizona" on old US 89 as well as existing US 89 from Flagstaff to Utah.

Nogales to Tucson

Zula's in Nogales and Wisdom's in Tumacacori are the only two survivors on this stretch.  Wisdom's is a "must stop" as a place with a unique pedigree unmatched anywhere else from Mexico to Canada.
All the other communities are populated with a typical array of eateries, none of which rise to the standards we've set for an ancestral US 89 dining establishment.

Tucson to Yarnell

We've been unable to find any legitimate old US 89 restaurants in this long stretch between  Tucson's Club 21 and Prescott's Hassayampa.  The Florence Cafe, 495 N Pinal Pkwy, serves a solid menu that replicates classic roadside Comfort Food.  Believe it or not, there are no old US 89 restaurants through Main Street Mesa, Tempe's Mill Avenue ot Van Buren Street in Phoenix.  Mel's on Grand Ave. is worth a stop for it's connection to the TV sitcom Alice. Whether is qualifies as a genuine old US 89 diner is debatable.  Wickenburg has its share of wannabe US 89 eateries and perhaps the Horseshoe Cafe, 207 East Wickenburg Way, might yet qualify for our coverage here.  It's definitely worth a stop to check it out.

Yarnell to Flagstaff via original US 89

After navigating the curvy White Spar Highway into Prescott, US 89 Heritage Travelers face a bewildering array of dining choices.  We featured the Hassayama Inn as "the" quintessential US 89 restaurant.  The Palace Saloon is another one, although people aren't generally known to visit the Whiskey Row icon for food.  There's nothing to mention on the original 1926-1940 US 89 alignment through Chino Valley, Paulden, Ash Fork.  Williams is another matter.  When US 89 reached Ash Fork, it shared the same pavement with Route 66 between Ask Fork and Townsend, Arizona, a few miles east of Flagstaff.  Therefore, any of the vintage Rt. 66 restaurants in Williams also by definition qualify as vintage US 89 restaurants.  The pedigrees of older Williams restaurants can be confusing and sometimes downright misleading.  We have chosen at this time to defer covering a Williams restaurant until we can be certain that we are reporting factual background information.  We have no doubts there remains a suitable candidate for our coverage.  However, we want to be sure we are picking and choosing the most suitable establishment of the many choices in Williams.

Prescott to Flagstaff via Arizona State Route 89A (formerly US 89A)

Although there are no true original US 89A diners or restaurants left on this long stretch of scenic highway, there are some solid choices to recommend.  Jerome's Haunted Hamburger will forever be in contention for the title of "Best Hamburger from Mexico to Canada."  Stop in at 410 Clark Street and see what you think about this important topic.  In Clarkdale check out the 10-12 Lounge at 910 Main Street.  Cottonwood has the rough-edged but much-loved Verde Lea Market at 516 N, Main St.
Sedona is a chaotic foodie fest.  None of Sedona kaleidoscopic array of restaurants qualifies as an original US 89 eatery.  That doesn't mean you'll pass through hungry.  Far from it.  There are simply too many Sedona choices to pick one over the rest.  You're on your own there!



Flagstaff to Utah via US 89A

After visiting the faithfully restored Grand Canyon Cafe in Flagstaff, US 89 Heritage Travelers will head north onto actual US 89.  The so-called Cameron Trading Post includes a semi-posh restaurant that is heavily patronized by the tour bus people.  Chances are pretty good that some sort of food as served there back in the 1930's  However, accounts of the establishments early years will forever obscured in the dust bin of history.  Farther north at Bitter Springs, there is a fork in the road.  Take it.

To the left, travelers follow the original US 89 that existed as the main highway from 1926 until the mid-1950's.  Just across historic Navajo Bridge sits Marble Canyon Lodge.  This historic site opened its doors not long after Navajo Bridge was finished and has been hosting weary, hungry motorists and Grand Canyon River Runners ever since.  The original place burned to the ground a few years back but was eventually replaced with a building that's faithful to its forebear.

Farther west on old US 89 (now known as US 89A) you will encounter Vermilion Cliffs, a small diner worth a look or an overnight stay.  Even slightly farther west  is Cliff Dwellers Lodge where yet another small diner is perched below the spectacular, colorful cliffs.  Proceeding on, travelers top out on the Kaibab Plateau at Jacob Lake.  During the tourist season there should be a cafe of some sort open for business there.  Jacob Lake has been a stopover site since long before automobile travel came along.  The remainder of the drive heads toward the Grand Staircase and goes through Fredonia.  There isn't any place to recommend in Fredonia but Kanab lies only a few miles north.

Flagstaff to Utah via US 89

At Bitter Springs, the now-main-highway bears to the right and climbs a steep hill to go through a remarkable narrow notch in the Echo Cliffs.  Many miles later, travelers will come to Page, Arizona, a city built on shifting desert sands because of a nearby dam.  Visitors to Lake Powell as a major factor in the age economy.  Therefore, restaurants and motel abound.  We doubt there are any original US 89 restaurants in Page but we could be wrong.  Someday we might actually bother to check.  We have nothing to recommend on this route. Pick your favorite fast food joint or go looking around so-called downtown Page for a restaurant with whatever theme and ambiance you may wish.  Otherwise move on along to Kanab where Parry Lodge and Trails End Cafe await.